pouët.net

seperation rating and comments?

category: general [glöplog]
 
hi
just a stray thourght, but maybe it would be generally better to seperate the comments from the ratings for the demos?
since the comment often is technically related, while the rating is not.
added on the 2006-09-20 16:46:46 by abductee abductee
why would the rating be unrelated with the technical details ?

consider thumbup + "good for a 4k"
I fail to see why they should be split. They are totally connected, 95% of people justify their rating with a comment...
Moreover, rating alone without a comment doesn't mean much, you usually want to know why a guy gave a prod a thumb up or down or a piggie.
added on the 2006-09-20 17:47:10 by keops keops
maybe the no comment thumbers simply agree with the previous comments matching their thumb
added on the 2006-09-20 18:02:54 by p01 p01
thats a very generalized maybe.
i often thumbed up without comment and not agreeing with what the majority of the other thumb uppers said.. O_o
added on the 2006-09-20 18:10:45 by psenough psenough

login