pouët.net

some feedback on the logo voting sytem

category: general [glöplog]
 
- the number of appearances of a logo (read: the probability that it's getting shown when a pages is loading) should be directly influenced by the voting. The better the voting, the better the probablility that it's getting shown, when the page is about to load.

- the "vote logos" link should be included in the main menu (between "users" and "random")

- the logos should be still viewable after the vote (just the "rulez" and "sucks" buttoms should disappear)

- a logo top-10 would be nice also

added on the 2002-08-20 21:12:29 by tomaes tomaes
well, agree to those suggestions from tomaes...

I was just wondering if when I vote a logo 'sucks' if it's just not shown for 'my account' anymore...or is it counted somewhere for a general 'chart' that is shown for any user then in the future...!??

That's a bit confusing with the current 'voting'-system I think...
added on the 2002-08-20 22:56:34 by Weasel Weasel
i think this is already happening, i cant see many of the disgusting logos ;-)

oh, and wheres my beutiful logo? =)
added on the 2002-08-20 23:08:11 by Hatikvah Hatikvah
It would also be nice to be able to vote for all the logos at the same time (radiobuttons for rulez/sucks and one 'submit' button a the bottom) so i wouldn't have to reload a shitload of big images after each vote.
added on the 2002-08-20 23:25:29 by uncle-x uncle-x
I'm a lamah.
Clicked almost only "sucks".
I prefered when you were a bastard Analogue ;)
(I know you're still one but... :D)
I agree with Tomaes ideas.
But, as I don't really count on other people's taste, I'd prefer that rulez & sucks directly influe on the logos I choose to see for myself. Should be part of the personnal account management in fact.
added on the 2002-08-21 00:13:24 by Splif Splif
I agree with Weasel about the user-specificness for showing logos (in fact, I think I was whining about it some time ago on #pouet.net) :)

Fair's fair: some people actually enjoy watching crap logos, and it would be a sin to deprave them from it just because the rest of us happen to hate it.

(At least Lator can enjoy his logo)
added on the 2002-08-21 00:17:13 by Shifter Shifter
Well, I don't really care if my logo is shown or not. It was made just for fun (tm) and for my surprise it made it to the database ;)
added on the 2002-08-21 00:36:57 by Crest Crest
the Rating system was fairly good. Either rulez or sucks. @_@; A vote has benefits for both sides, analogue doesn't have to be a bitch anymore, for throwing out logos and we can choose them for ourselfs.. :D
added on the 2002-08-21 02:07:51 by elend elend
lator, YOUR beautiful logo? Dunno, but mine is added now.
added on the 2002-08-21 11:33:56 by steffo steffo
Where are my glops? I had exactly 1020??? Anyways,. perhaps it's better with 1009 now, because I can review 1,2 more entries now (but slowly, slowly..)
Something else. If i click on my self I don't get the whole list of the things I added. That was bad imho. I remember having reviewed an old prod which I wanted to find again. I could remember the name by looking on my whole list, but now there is no big list. It's impossible to find which demo was this now. It was a demo with some violent animations, but was funny and funny sound fx,. with someone upon a building shooting another one in another building, but he oculdn't kill him and got mad, and suicided and when he was an angel he saw him in front of him and poped. Ok,. I know I am writting funny, but I woke up early on the morning, played some Z-doom and got motionsicknessed and am lioma sto xoma,.. tell me the name of the demo if you rmember or some other hints to search for it!
added on the 2002-08-21 11:51:28 by Optimonk Optimonk
stefamcrs: haha!! ripper!! ;-)
added on the 2002-08-21 12:10:20 by Hatikvah Hatikvah
Hmm the problem with stef #2's logo is that if you don't know about brainfuck the programming language, it's sorta lame.
added on the 2002-08-21 12:30:27 by Factory Factory

My suggestion with the calculated appearance based on votes would have the advantage what ALL logos have the chance to be shown, only that the ones with good voting results would be shown much more often. I mean, there are 100(?) logos in total, and I only get to see the same old logos again and again (yes, I admit most of 'em ARE good).

Optimus: Analouge told me, that he made a database integrity check, and so, fake glöps caused by bugged code etc. were removed. Could be the reason...
added on the 2002-08-21 12:59:32 by tomaes tomaes
Factory, i think it looks like nuskoolart if you dont know brainfuck, wich people tend to like :)
added on the 2002-08-21 13:05:14 by Hatikvah Hatikvah
i think all 'accepted' logos should have an equal chance of getting shown.
I would also vote for an equal chance for all 'selected' logos in the end...
When I saw the huge list of logos where you can vote I also found out that I just get to see like 30-40% of the logos on the normal pouet-pages. The rest I'Ve never seen before...although there are really great pieces among them...

I also vote for radio-buttons to vote with and a kinda chart where everyone can see how the logos are rated in general from the users...

...but analogue doesn't reply here... ;-)))))
added on the 2002-08-21 17:26:20 by Weasel Weasel
ile: There is just one problem. What is the definition of 'accepted'? 50% must like it (and voted rulez) would be fair I think (although still quite hard, because a lot of people seem to have voted sucks for almost all logos).
added on the 2002-08-21 17:45:57 by tomaes tomaes
Weasel: I'm not replying but I'm reading, go on =)
added on the 2002-08-21 18:12:17 by analogue analogue
well i dont know how analogue did it now, but i'm suggesting something like if a logo gets twice as many rulez as sucks or whatever, it is 'accepted'

i dont think 'personalised' settings are that nice in this case though...
personalized settings would rock..
how hard could it be to hide all the logos someone voted "sucks" on? :-) we would more or less get skinned stuff, but with 'free' skins, as in logos.. would rock :)
added on the 2002-08-21 20:24:17 by Hatikvah Hatikvah
Oh my god, there's so much shit : (
please aNa|0Gue, be a "Fucker" again !
added on the 2002-08-21 23:55:02 by p01 p01
aNa|0Gue: did you usually received so much logos ? or have you been spammed of "logos" since you installed the voting system ?

If you don't want to moderate the logos again, I vote both for the sucks/rulez radios and for the personalized settings
added on the 2002-08-22 00:26:06 by p01 p01

login