| Sine Fiction by Charged [web] | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|||||||
|
popularity : 50% |
|||||||
alltime top: #93017 |
|
|||||||
|
||||||||
added on the 2026-11-08 11:24:34 by SplAtEE  |
||||||||
popularity helper
comments
Contains AI generated content
added on the 2026-11-08 11:25:19 by SplAtEE
sucks
There are some cool ideas, but why vibe the whole thing :\
Not my vibe
Slop
I completely fail to see what the point of productions like this is. The graphics are AI generated, the music is a bunch of old tunes and the code is AI generated, the effects and design are derivative (and the pacing / flow of the demo is slow). It's like a very average C64 demo from 20 years ago, but without even the effort of doing it by hand. At least that way there would be some level of "craft" involved.
As a sidenote before anyone points it out: there is of course nothing new about re-using other people's tunes, graphics or code, the very first demos / crack intros etc were prone to doing that. That aspect has always been around. But rarely it's been so that there is nearly nothing of "value added" in a production of this size by whomever put it together.
What I would like to truly understand is what exactly is the creative part here (and in similar AI-creations). What is the spark, the essence or idea the author had, apart from "make a generic demo with some 'math stuff'" and what kind of sense of accomplishment can one gain from producing something like this. As it stands, I am unable to wrap my brain around the mindset that could see any fun in this.
As a sidenote before anyone points it out: there is of course nothing new about re-using other people's tunes, graphics or code, the very first demos / crack intros etc were prone to doing that. That aspect has always been around. But rarely it's been so that there is nearly nothing of "value added" in a production of this size by whomever put it together.
What I would like to truly understand is what exactly is the creative part here (and in similar AI-creations). What is the spark, the essence or idea the author had, apart from "make a generic demo with some 'math stuff'" and what kind of sense of accomplishment can one gain from producing something like this. As it stands, I am unable to wrap my brain around the mindset that could see any fun in this.
Quote:
Contains AI generated content
I'd ask my AI agent to watch and summarize it for me, but I ran out of tokens.
The future is not here.
Based on the credits listed in the CSDb, it seems that the "creator’s" only contribution was turning on the machine. I hate giving "sucks" ratings, but I just can’t get support this. Isn’t it a better feeling to learn and grow? To create by putting something of yourself into it—your creativity, your experiences?
and finally, a quote from the CSDb: "The era of the posers"
and finally, a quote from the CSDb: "The era of the posers"
Bin
wth again
what ccr said
What ccr said.
I'm going to give a "thumbs up" for at least being honest about how this was made. Something that other productions often lack, IMHO.
Slöp.
I like some of the wordplays. Hopefully those were human ideas at least.
@ccr: Way back in the nineties me and my friends made an amiga „megademo“ only consisting of demos made with demomakers, because no one of us was able to code. Maybe if there was something like the internet at this time we would have uploaded it to a site like pouet too. But we made the gfx and music ourselves at least. So to answer your question I think the fun in making a prod like „sine fiction“ is to have an idea and develop it on your own without the months/years of learning the tools. The gfx alone in this would be a huge(!) amount of work if it done by a human. The only thing which I find inconsistent is that the music wasn’t done by AI too.
@ccr: Way back in the nineties me and my friends made an amiga „megademo“ only consisting of demos made with demomakers, because no one of us was able to code. Maybe if there was something like the internet at this time we would have uploaded it to a site like pouet too. But we made the gfx and music ourselves at least. So to answer your question I think the fun in making a prod like „sine fiction“ is to have an idea and develop it on your own without the months/years of learning the tools. The gfx alone in this would be a huge(!) amount of work if it done by a human. The only thing which I find inconsistent is that the music wasn’t done by AI too.
Quote:
…to have an idea and develop it on your own without the months/years of learning the tools.
Why? Because the idea is so marvelous?
what ccr said
Quote:
I like some of the wordplays. Hopefully those were human ideas at least.
Quote:
The only thing which I find inconsistent is that the music wasn’t done by AI too.
Don't really get the comments but wouldn't it be ultra consistent, if the wordplays were by AI also?
From Sir Art's comment on CSDB:
Emphasis mine. This is what I have been suspecting for a while, that this stuff costs a lot of money to produce. This is the saddest part of the whole problem, that people are throwing their money away for the sake of saving time they could have spent learning or interacting anyway (i.e. becoming more independent). These AI slop demos do not result from an act of creation or an act of production, but from an act of consumption.
Quote:
Most AI-generated stuff is still AI slop, and making something worthwhile is surprisingly demanding — both mentally and financially...
Emphasis mine. This is what I have been suspecting for a while, that this stuff costs a lot of money to produce. This is the saddest part of the whole problem, that people are throwing their money away for the sake of saving time they could have spent learning or interacting anyway (i.e. becoming more independent). These AI slop demos do not result from an act of creation or an act of production, but from an act of consumption.
At least the financial part puts a limit on the amount of slop produced, for now.
Quote:
throwing their money away
If these people are working in tech then they're probably using their company tokens.
Why? Because you can?
It is so funny, your nick and what you are doing.
It is so funny, your nick and what you are doing.
Sir, this is a Wendy's
okay?
@serp: Fair point.
Quote:
this is a Wendy's
shoot, i stepped into the random restaurant portal again :(
No
It's a shame, as normally I would like to see such demos with more mathematical fractal effects even if other parts suffered.
Mainly pre rendered animations and thats a shame.
3d attractor anim looks dope though!
Julia morpher is the only good real time
calculated effect here.
Mandelbrot zoomer does not come close to that
Anim from attack of stubidos 3 by beyond force.
IFS fractals look bad/ugly. Bezier cube too slow
To enjoy. Sorry ai, you are still not that good.
Better and better though.
3d attractor anim looks dope though!
Julia morpher is the only good real time
calculated effect here.
Mandelbrot zoomer does not come close to that
Anim from attack of stubidos 3 by beyond force.
IFS fractals look bad/ugly. Bezier cube too slow
To enjoy. Sorry ai, you are still not that good.
Better and better though.
submit changes
if this prod is a fake, some info is false or the download link is broken,
do not post about it in the comments, it will get lost.
instead, click here !